Guide · updated November 17, 2026
My California home insurance was non-renewed. What do I do now?
A practical order of steps after a California non-renewal notice: dates, documents, the regular market, and when the FAIR Plan comes up.
A non-renewal notice means the carrier will not continue your policy past the date on the letter. It is not the same as a cancellation for nonpayment, and it is usually not a judgment about you personally. In recent years, many California notices have followed a carrier’s wildfire or business decisions.
Read the date before you do anything else
Find the last day of coverage and put it on a calendar. If you have a mortgage, the lender cares about a gap as much as you do. The useful move is to start weeks before that date, not the Friday before.
Keep the notice. Keep the declarations page for the policy that is ending. Those two documents tell a broker what you have now and when it stops.
Talk with a broker before you assume the FAIR Plan is next
The California Department of Insurance recommends speaking with an agent or broker before you turn to the FAIR Plan. A regular-market homeowners policy, when one is available, is built as a broader package than the FAIR Plan’s basic fire policy.
An independent broker can ask more than one carrier. A captive agent can offer only that one company. If the company that non-renewed you is a captive company, a broker at a different firm is often the next call. Fast Forward Insurance Services can look at the carriers we represent. We cannot quote companies that sell only through their own agents.
Send the notice and the declarations page with your address, the year the home was built, and the roof age and type if you know them. Photos of the roof and of the space around the house help when the concern is wildfire.
If the regular market says no
Then the FAIR Plan is the backstop for fire coverage. It mainly covers fire and smoke. Plan on a separate Difference in Conditions policy for gaps such as liability, theft, and some water damage. The FAIR Plan does not sell that DIC policy. Our FAIR Plan and DIC page explains the pair.
Do not let the current policy expire while you are still comparing. A lapse creates its own problems with carriers and with your lender.
What we will not tell you
We will not tell you the non-renewal was a mistake, and we will not promise another carrier will say yes. We will tell you what we found for that address. Start with the home insurance page or request a quote.
This guide is general information from Fast Forward Insurance Services, CA License 0M92193. Your policy forms control. Request a quote or call 833-342-5334 during business hours.
